July 20, 2021
Death threats and bookshop fines: Hungary faces scrutiny over anti-LGBTQ ruling
by Nikki Griffiths
In 2020, Hungary passed a law preventing citizens from legally changing their gender. Later that year, they decided to ban same-sex couples from adopting children. Only last month, a law was passed in parliament banning any depiction of LQBTQ people from featuring in school educational materials or children’s television shows. And now the country, ruled by right-wing autocrat Viktor Orbán, has issued a fine to a bookshop chain for selling a children’s book deemed “corrupting” for daring to depict a rainbow family.
Pest County, a Hungarian local authority, has fined bookshop chain Líra Könyv 250,000 forints ($835.95) for selling Micsoda család! a Hungarian translation combining two titles by US author Lawrence Schimel and illustrator Elīna Brasliņa, Early One Morning and Not Playtime! The stories depict the daily routines of two children, one with two mothers and one with two fathers.
Richard Tarnai, a Pest County official told Hungarian television station HirTV’s evening talk show that the book’s Hungarian distributor, the Foundation for Rainbow Families, had violated rules on unfair commercial practices, saying:
“The book was there among other fairytale books and thus committed a violation … There is no way of knowing that this book is about a family that is different than a normal family.”
In a Facebook post on Wednesday, the Foundation for Rainbow Families responded with vigor, saying:
“Rainbow families are completely normal, ordinary families … The story book presents simple, everyday stories, the sexuality of parents is not even a topic.”
Author Schimel told the Guardian that the idea for the books was to:
“celebrate queer families, to put more queer joy into the world, so that the only books available to children weren’t about conflicts…
“In these stories, the fact that the parents are two mums or two dads is incidental to the story, as it is to the daily lives of children in rainbow families. These families don’t only experience homophobia, they also have fun.”
Líra Könyv posted a statement on Facebook warning of the slippery censorship slope ahead should the local authorities keep acting in such a rash way. Nevertheless, they also declared that as a preventive measure, they would issues signs at the entrances to all of their bookshops, declaring “we sell books with different content than traditional ones.”
The ugly fallout of recent events includes Schimel’s Hungarian editor, Boldizsar Nagy, who is gay himself, receiving abuse and death threats. He told the Thomson Reuters Foundation:
“I fear a little bit and that is why (myself and my partner) plan to leave the country…
Fierce opposition came from the EU, with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen telling the European Parliament the law is “a disgrace” saying, “This legislation uses the protection of children as an excuse to discriminate against people because of their sexual orientation.”
As the BBC reported, the European Parliament went on to vote in favour of urgent legal action over Hungary’s new law, including a possible reduction in budget allocations to member states in breach of the rule of law and calling for Hungary’s government to be held accountable at the European Court of Justice. But how long will action take, and how likely is that to stop a bigoted, power hungry leader with who insists he is defending Hungary’s Christian values?
Nikki Griffiths is the managing director of Melville House UK.